THE ILLS OF A WISCONSIN COP
Reviewed By: Kathy Kahn
Former San Jose security guard, Sylvester
Harris, had a rough time a black cop in Racine, Wis.
He had expected as much, as he recalls in
"A reason For Being," when the mayor first asked him to join the
police department in 1967. He had been beaten up by cops as a kid growing
up on the wrong side of the tracks in Racine. by 1967, he was an angry
young protester, dodging police batons in street demonstrations.
Harris turned down the mayor's job offer at
first, he writes, skeptical that he could improve police behavior by
working from the inside. at the time, police jobs were opening up to
young men like Harris, yet racial tension was breaking out into open violence, and a backlash
had started. There were still only a few black
officers, he said, and the whites distrusted and resented them. One
of Harris' assignments, to investigate complaints of police brutality
against black citizens, didn't help him win friends among his new white
colleagues.
His account of 10 years on the force is a
story of doubled standards, one tale after another of how differently
white and black citizens were treated by the police, and how white and black
cops ere treated by their department. It's also the one man story of
how the civil rights movement reached a dead end. after a decade of
fighting the system, Harris fled the cold streets of Racine for a private
job in warmer California.
on his way out of town, Harris won an
extraordinary legal victory over the local law-enforcement establishment
and was awarded more than $250,000 in damages.
It started on a winter evening in 1974, when
Harris stopped a car for a traffic infraction, and the driver pulled a gun
on him. The driver turned out to be a paroled robber who went to the
district attorney, and said that Harris had come to his house two days
after the arrest and beaten him. Harris remained free while the district attorney
ensured the accusations.
From the start, Harris says the case was
unfairly tried in the press. Even the parolee's recantation of the story
at a meeting in the mayors office didn't stop the presiding judge from repeatedly
denouncing Harris in public, the author contends. After two years on the defensive, Harris counterattacked with a civil rights suit in federal
court. His victory, upheld on appeal in 1979, is a minor legal landmark,
and this alone, makes his book historically noteworthy.
The real story here, is not the legal
victory, but the personal toll is took on the cop who won it. Harris' narration
in angry, emotional and rough-edged: charges of racism fly thick
and fast at many of the people he encounters. For the reader who might
wonder if the very large chip on Harris' shoulder contributed to his
problems, here's the federal court's summary of the case: "The
copious evidence of racial motivation... was overwhelming... a public and
private campaign of vilification."
Harris writes movingly on the emotional strain, sleepless nights and physical illness brought on by his daily
battles. and he tells of the moment when he stood up in federal court,
nearly in tears, to explain himself and all the contradictions of his
life, inside and outside the systems: "How could I tell, this
all-white jury that the salvation of the American black man is encompassed
in the hands of the white man? It is not because I want to believe that
the white global collective holds within them, our destiny, but it is truly
what the American black man believes."
...Harris' story reminds white readers that
racism hurts the heart and sole, not just the pocketbook.
Review of "A Reason for Being: The
Syl Harris Story"
San Francisco Chronicle - San Francisco, California
January 28, 1990 |